Da 5 Bloods: Race, Trauma, and Healing


Four Vietnam War veterans reunite to honor their fifth fallen comrade and return to the field of battle to retrieve gold they buried there decades ago. 

It's been 45 years, but the war never really ended, just as all wars never really end, for the people who participated in them, for the people they indirectly affect, for the land they take place in. The trauma of war is merely buried, like gold in a hillside, never completely destroyed, waiting to be unearthed—and, as with their squabbles over who gets what portion of the gold, everybody argues among themselves about who deserves their trauma. 

Greed does not just apply to gold, these men are greedy for their entitlement to their own pain. African American soldiers are traumatized by fighting a war for a country that does not care about them, and Vietnamese citizens are traumatized by having a war fought against them in their country by people who do not care about them, and now they're fighting over who has the moral high ground rather than processing that trauma and trying to heal. 

This is what's so tricky about Spike Lee's portrait of victimhood here: the Black soldiers and the Vietnamese citizens are both victims of American military imperialism, but that doesn't make them infallible. They still have their own flaws, their own unquestioned ideological prejudices. But the moments of healing come not from the conflict between them, but from their quiet introspection; healing doesn't come from fighting, it comes from crying. 


But no one is rewarded for healing, the same way no one is rewarded with entitlement for their victimhood. The war rages on whether we deal with our trauma or not—and not just the Vietnam War, but the wars here at home as well. America is at war with Black people; it has been since its inception, and it still is to this day. Slavery and the Civil War may have "officially" ended, but the trauma lives on, buried gold waiting to be dug up.

This is where the brilliant formal conceit comes in, the use of shifting aspect ratios, originally switching between the square 1.33:1 and the ultra-wide 2.35:1 and eventually settling on the standard widescreen 1.77:1, and the blending of fictional narrative with documentary footage, jumping from historical photography to fictional scenes. The superficial distinctions between past and present are erased to give us one singular truth.

War never really ends, we just have to do the best we can to let our wounds heal and get back in the battle. Black lives may not matter yet in America, but we will fight until they do.

O, yes,
I say it plain,
America never was America to me,
And yet I swear this oath—
America will be!

Related Lists:

Comments

  1. Great review! I like your comment about the shifting aspect ratios and how it breaks down past and present. These scenes also struck me as profoundly a-temporal, notably the choice to use the aging actors in the scenes of wartime, combined with what can only be described as overbearing patriotic music and the aspect ratio of an old TV all contributed to an odd unreal, out of time sort of vibe. On the one hand, we could see these as satirical scenes criticizing the patriotic imagery of the Vietnam war and our glorification of violence; or, on the other hand, we could see these scenes as legitimate flashbacks from the characters' point of view, combining their present emotional age, with their deeply traumatic past. Either way, these moments are out of time, and heavily influenced by both imagery of the past and the eternal trauma you discuss here. Thanks for discussing it!

    ReplyDelete
  2. We are the top leading escort agency provide for a long time. We do everything just to make our clients happy when they hire our escort services. Hence we have only High-Profile and VIP Call Girls in Ahmedabad. They are well educated models who their work properly. Our models are well trained as well as expert in their profession. You only need to share your emotions and desires with them, after that they will ensure you to take the advantage of mesmerizing secret services in private room. There are also lots of services available at our Ahmedabad Escort. You can access them all and make your life more exciting than before.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment